Skip to main content

Subscribe

Laws Against Narcissism

 Laws Against Narcissism

Photo by Tingey Injury Law Firm on Unsplash

Judiciary Law

This is a tough issue to grapple with as a whole but there is a very specific reason as to why there can’t be laws against narcissistic abuse and by connection conviction for insidious narcissistic abuse.

Okay, first — why this can’t be done.

There are laws in place already which cover narcissistic abuse. They are called laws.

They apply to narcissists and regular people, and they are to be applied without bias and to the appropriate extent as interpreted by a judge often by past precedent. The crux of this problem is simplified like this:

A regular person is found guilty of manslaughter and goes to jail for 5 years

A narcissist is found guilty of manslaughter and goes to jail for what? 8 years?

Why would narcissistic manslaughter be worth more than regular manslaughter? What’s the difference that would necessitate a longer sentence?

We have laws against attacking someone, we have laws against murder, stealing, etc. etc. Basically, every physical crime has a law for it so how do we create special narcissist laws where when you line them up against the regular laws it is little more than favoritism and punishment? Unfortunately, that is not going to happen because of the constitutionality of the whole idea.

Basically, to make special narcissist laws we would have to make sure we have a way of identifying who those laws apply to right? So now we are talking about lists of registered narcissists that would exist. Then who gets access to these lists? Just the police? What about airlines? Or bouncers? etc. If these lists are published, then there are privacy concerns as we just published a diagnosed health issue on a list of people without their consent.

Further, with this list we just took a minority population who have a diagnosed mental health problem who may never have been convicted of a thing, and we classified, segregated them virtually and have created a hit list for anyone with a grudge against narcissistic — I know , seems far fetched people would hold that kind of grudge but believe me there are some very hurt and angry people after these relationships.

If civilization started to break down due to a prolonged depression or war then these lists can really quickly become genocide death camp lists.

What about Emotional Abuse?

Right, that’s a good point. What? Don’t we have laws against emotional abuse?

Well, in many cases there are but they are covered under the Domestic Violence laws. In terms of a legal definition Emotional Abuse isn’t defined because it’s such a hard concept to put brackets around because it is so situational and individualized that to define it would be impossible. There is no standard definition per se but it does have some commonalities that can be defined.

It typically contains:

  • Verbal aggression which includes lies and false statements about the other person.
  • Dominating or repressive behavior to create a subordinate or obedience out of another individual.
  • Implanting ideas of jealousy or slander of another individual
  • Forcing someone to view disturbing images, videos, or behavior.

The law recognizes emotional distress as a state of mental suffering that occurs because of negligence or intentional acts of another, usually physical in nature. Emotional distress is exhibited by feelings of shame, humiliation, insomnia, depression, self-destructive thoughts, anxiety, stress, or another emotional response from a traumatic event.

Typically, in order to sue for monetary compensation there has to be a physical aspect to the abuse. However, as of June of 2019 most courts recognize the right to award monetary damages for non-physical emotional distress claims where there is sexual harassment or defamation.

Most legal actions that get filed with regards to emotional abuse are under the laws that cover Negligent Infliction of Emotional Distress (NEID) and Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress (IIED).

IIED reefers to someone who recklessly intentionally behaves in a way that is extreme or outrageous which causes another person to suffer severe emotional distress or trauma.

Individuals can receive compensatory and punitive damages, but the challenge is in proving that there was mental harm. Someone saying or doing something that embarrasses you would not qualify but, if the person knew you had PTSD and kept subjecting you to that trauma that may qualify.

NEID is similar to IIED but the persons actions were not intentional but must have acted in a negligent manner and the victim must prove they suffered some type of physical injury as well. A case where a family member sees their loved one die due to a drunk driver would qualify.

So What is the Gap?

First, we wouldn’t need narcissistic laws of emotional abuse for the same argument that I have stated above where abuse laws apply equally to all individuals in order for those laws not to be discriminatory in themselves. So emotional abuse laws would apply to any abusive situation not just if the person was diagnosed as a narcissist.

Non-physical emotional abuse such as sexual harassment and defamation have greater transparency because of the overt nature of the acts themselves. It gets harder to prove when the events don’t fit within those brackets and for a few different reasons.

Emotional abuse does not leave physical marks.

The person needs to have seen a therapist or doctor that has diagnosed PTSD (Its not a requirement but is near impossible to prove emotional distress without an objective professional opinion.

The subjective nature of emotional abuse. Its customized and individualized so what is extremely distressing for one individual may be a total joke to another.

Proving intent to harm by utilizing whichever strategy that caused the emotional distress.

Emotional distress claims have a statute of limitations on them of 2 years. Outrageous conduct means more than insulting, threats, annoyances, and petty oppressive actions. So, someone yelling at you and swearing saying they hope you die is not considered outrageous conduct but if they maliciously told you that your daughter or son was dead, that could qualify.

Emotional distress claims can be cost prohibitive because of the need to have professionals that can attest to the damage being done, hiring of expert witnesses, building the pool of evidence to support the claim.

Limitations/Gaps/Shortcomings

As far as the law is concerned:

  • You need to be able to prove that the damage to your mental health was done. So, the burden of proof is on the victim.
  • Due to the subjective nature of emotional distress an expert will be needed to testify on your behalf.
  • It does not take into consideration the accumulated effects of long-term abuse.
  • The existing laws around restraining orders are viewed as sufficient when there is no physical threat present, but it doesn’t take into consideration attachment trauma and trauma bonding.

Basically, the existing laws look at physical separation as the answer for emotional abuse. That does not take into consideration when financial abuse is present, and the victim is simply unable to leave due to not having a place to go or any money to leave.

Granted there are shelters etc but that tis a difficult step to take filled with uncertainty for someone who likely has no self-esteem or self-assuredness. Still, there is merit in the notion that someone has to help themselves as well as the world around you can’t save you — its a decision you have to make and act on.

Having said that, the law doesn’t really consider attachment trauma and the trauma bond and what an incredibly strong impact that can have on an individual if they are unaware of what is driving their compulsion toward their abuser.

The fact that insults and cut downs are not actionable doesn’t consider the accumulated affects of being subjected to that, but again — the law’s position is for physical separation and if the victim is not using restraining orders or do not contact orders to get that separation then at what point is the victim responsible for themselves?

So what can we do?

We can get the members of Parliament or whatever you have down there, the Congress I guess — and have them put forward a motion to toughen up certain punishments for certain crimes but then those laws would apply to everyone not just one small group of people - it's fair. It's not flashy but if there is a deficiency that would be how to address it.

We can try to get awareness around the trauma bond and attachment trauma as well as the accumulative nature of the lesser abuses like name calling etc. If professionals can figure out a way to quantify or prove the trauma bond itself keeps a victim trapped in that circumstance, then it might be actionable.

The trouble is really illustrated by the Johnny Depp and Amber Heard situation in that as things escalate there most often is reactive abuse so potentially both parties are trauma bonded to one another and both are guilty of the accumulative minor attacks.

The best bet is to get a long-standing record of the emotional abuse with a professional documenting it.

Is that enough?

No. The problem isn’t necessarily the laws that are in place it's the interpretation of those laws and those on the front line not being educated as to how abuse can look so they often take the abuser's side.

All of these positions in the law or anywhere that has to deal with the public and make a call as to right or wrong needs to be trained in disorders. Even director level and Managers should be in organizations, but someone would have to start that drive to make that awareness. Not many are willing to after escaping a relationship as they are just finally glad to have some peace.

What can we do to protect ourselves?

Boundaries. Its proven that narcissists like to rush things in the beginning. If people kept firm boundaries and didn’t bend on them the narcissist would give up and move onto someone easier before they got close enough to ruin your life.

This could look like dating them one night a week for the first month and never going to their place or your place — do the date and leave to go home. Do that for a month and that narcissist will either be gone or will have had some type of a meltdown on you for not letting them get close.

The crux of emotional abuse is the victim has weak boundaries. They put up with it. They are patient, they are forgiving, they are their own biggest problem because they allow themselves to be subjected to this mistreatment in the first place.

With healthy boundaries you will not put up with someone cutting you down and insulting you.

You will not have fallen in love or gotten trauma bonded to that individual because the first cut down or two wouldn’t have been shrugged off there would have been a warning given. The second cutdown a separation.

It is the lack of those boundaries that makes victims ‘pass the test’ that they are given and subjects them to the hot and cold treatment that would imprison them in the relationship

Boundaries are the answer — not tolerating what you would never do to a kid or a stranger….don’t allow your significant other to do to you..

The distance and the time boundary will work wonders at protecting yourself against future narcissists.


Most Viewed This Year

Dark Psychology - Manipulation

  Dark Psychology There are many different psychological mechanisms that are  present in society on a daily basis.    These mechanism utilize a person's fears and their ability to interpret messages that their aggressor wishes for them to have.    Everywhere from the office to the club, to your very own home, you are subjected to various forms of manipulation from people.     Manipulation has a bad rap.    People believe that manipulation is a bad thing because of how it makes them feel when they find out that they have been manipulated.   People get upset because it makes them feel like a lesser person, like they have been victimized in some way, and often like they are not intelligent.    Manipulation can be used for good purposes however.    In the case of a newborn baby the very first thing it learns how to do in order to survive is to cry.    By crying they trigger their mother to come an...

What you need to know about Codependency

  What you need to know about Codependency Photo by Morgan Housel on Usplash Attachment Style Codependency roots from an attachment trauma that a child received in their early years. There are many different causes for attachment trauma ranging from neglect, to child abuse, to the main caregiver becoming ill or hurt, necessity for survival (working for food), to the baby itself being sick or in a lot of pain. Codependency typically accompanies an anxious style of attachment. It is the inverse of narcissism because the narcissists attachment trauma typically manifests itself in an avoidant attachment style. Once a child has an anxious attachment style — if they have any instability at home or some perceived threat to their security they will often move into a people pleaser role growing up. They will attempt to take care of the needs of their caregiver or to avert disturbing temper flares by catering to them and by being the good child at the beckon call of the parent. Arise my Peop...

How is a narcissist affected by someone who rejects them romantically?

 How is a narcissist affected by someone who rejects them romantically? Photo by  Warren  on  Unsplash I have a slightly different take on this one than most people. Usually, people believe that narcissists think that they're God's gift to the earth which they do create that aura around them. They do talk like they believe it and they do act like they believe it. So as a result, people believe that why narcissists react so horribly to the rejection of a romantic interest is because they cannot accept that somebody wouldn't want them. I believe it's the other way around. I believe that for the vast majority of narcissists their fear of rejection is rooted in their childhood. They are actually hurt when they're acting this way because it actually touches a core wound of theirs around rejection. It touches that wound around why they actually have low self-esteem and don't believe in themselves. This is the true route of why they can't let it go. The other ones ...

Crowd Favorites

Dark Psychology - Manipulation

  Dark Psychology There are many different psychological mechanisms that are  present in society on a daily basis.    These mechanism utilize a person's fears and their ability to interpret messages that their aggressor wishes for them to have.    Everywhere from the office to the club, to your very own home, you are subjected to various forms of manipulation from people.     Manipulation has a bad rap.    People believe that manipulation is a bad thing because of how it makes them feel when they find out that they have been manipulated.   People get upset because it makes them feel like a lesser person, like they have been victimized in some way, and often like they are not intelligent.    Manipulation can be used for good purposes however.    In the case of a newborn baby the very first thing it learns how to do in order to survive is to cry.    By crying they trigger their mother to come an...

Why is there an addiction to narcissistic partners?

Why is there an addiction to narcissistic partners? This is just my personal theory on the topic as I’ve thought a lot about variances of this question and my own situation. This is what I have come up with as to why:  Enmeshment - enmeshment often gets spoken about from the abusers perspective. Where they purposefully inject themselves into someone else's life and take control and influence over everything and using it as a means to isolate them from their supports. There is a different version of enmeshment that occurs with narcissism that has the narcissist get their significant other into all of the aspects within the narcissists life. So, they assign them duties and tasks that are integrated right into the narcissists life. These keep getting added on as the relationship continues and more and more of these aspects of the narcissists life becomes the significant others responsibility. It can get to the point where the significant other has no time at all for the things they...

How is a narcissist affected by someone who rejects them romantically?

 How is a narcissist affected by someone who rejects them romantically? Photo by  Warren  on  Unsplash I have a slightly different take on this one than most people. Usually, people believe that narcissists think that they're God's gift to the earth which they do create that aura around them. They do talk like they believe it and they do act like they believe it. So as a result, people believe that why narcissists react so horribly to the rejection of a romantic interest is because they cannot accept that somebody wouldn't want them. I believe it's the other way around. I believe that for the vast majority of narcissists their fear of rejection is rooted in their childhood. They are actually hurt when they're acting this way because it actually touches a core wound of theirs around rejection. It touches that wound around why they actually have low self-esteem and don't believe in themselves. This is the true route of why they can't let it go. The other ones ...

What you need to know about Codependency

  What you need to know about Codependency Photo by Morgan Housel on Usplash Attachment Style Codependency roots from an attachment trauma that a child received in their early years. There are many different causes for attachment trauma ranging from neglect, to child abuse, to the main caregiver becoming ill or hurt, necessity for survival (working for food), to the baby itself being sick or in a lot of pain. Codependency typically accompanies an anxious style of attachment. It is the inverse of narcissism because the narcissists attachment trauma typically manifests itself in an avoidant attachment style. Once a child has an anxious attachment style — if they have any instability at home or some perceived threat to their security they will often move into a people pleaser role growing up. They will attempt to take care of the needs of their caregiver or to avert disturbing temper flares by catering to them and by being the good child at the beckon call of the parent. Arise my Peop...

The Secret to Making It Work with a Covert Narcissist

  The Secret to Making It Work with a Covert Narcissist Photo by Randy Jacob on Unsplash If you are someone that is in love with your covert narcissist then there is one secret tactic that you’ll absolutely need to have in place if you are going to last any length of time with your self-esteem and self-worth intact. You love your narcissist. You love it when we make you feel special and you feel like you are elevated when you are with us. Like the two of us form an elite team that is better than everyone and you’re proud to be part of something so awesome that it makes you feel great. We have an energy and a presence when we enter into any room and it seems like people want to hear what we have to say - they seem value you a little more for some reason and it seems like they look up to us in some way because of our relationship.. It’s all very strange but somewhat intoxicating as well. Its the illusion that you buy into. The only problem is that Ineed to pick apart the things that ...

Are there other ways in which narcissistic rage manifests besides yelling and arguing?

 Are there other ways in which narcissistic rage manifests besides yelling and arguing? Photo by Kristina Flour on Unsplash Yes, the rage can manifest itself in the worst way imaginable. Silence. But oh no, not the silence you they use as punishment during a normal drag you down cycle. This one is special. In the immediate moments after a narcissistic injury is sustained and their emotions become dysregulated there can almost be a frantic grasping at reasons and connecting of events to outcomes that never even occurred all with the sole purpose of offloading as much fault and blame onto you as possible. Its almost like the shame meter hits a tipping point and there is an overspilling of shame that has to go somewhere so it is going to you. You will be blamed for things that you were not even present for and deals/agreements made will be completely spun another way to place you as a doer of wrongs. You might get told to never talk to them again or they will file a restraining order...

Gaslighting - rewriting history by changing your memories

  Gaslighting — The Rewriting of History Photo by  Toa Heftiba  on  Unsplash I would suspect that if you are aware of gas lighting then you’re aware of how most abusers use it to try to get out of trouble and to try to flip the script so that you’re the one that is on defense. They try to make it so that they never have to feel that shame and they never have to be the bad guy. They can be the perpetual victim and they can always be the one telling the sob story for the sympathy hit, or they can be the justified avenger that finally had enough. In all cases you’re the bad guy and they are the good guy but, it’s petty enough and childish enough that it doesn’t really effect you, despite the annoyance of someone denying what you know to be true. True gaslighting is much more insidious than that. If you’re truly the target of someone with real malintent in mind then this person will sadistically try to break you down mentally and emotionally with the ultimate goal of com...

Is it Good to be a Psychopath?

  Is it good to be a psychopath? Photo by Sivani Bandaru on Unsplash People often treat psychopathy like it’s some type of super power. As if it makes for a superior human being because of the lack of fear and the inability to manipulate them through emotional appeals. Sure, they have an edge when it comes to escalating things as nothing scares them so they naturally are able to keep cranking up the stakes until you can’t escalate anymore. That is an advantage. Taking things to the extreme is what they are good at, while ensuring that they are in a power position over whomever they are dealing with. If they can’t be in a power position then they’ll never get involved. This is why it’s so hard to beat a psychopath. If you’re in a winner takes all situation you can bet that they feel like they have some edge on you so you need to think really hard about what is going on in order to see why they feel that way, or else you’ll find yourself screwed in the end. The psychopath is the expe...

You are wrong about your narcissist

  You Are Wrong About Your Narcissist Photo by  Andrej Lišakov  on  Unsplash Psychologists will often not believe you if you tell them that your spouse is a narcissist for a couple reasons. The first is that people often don’t truly understand what a narcissist is, and the second is because people are often incorrect with their assessment despite knowing what narcissism is. People can’t diagnose their loved ones. The argument that people can’t diagnose family members roots from a couple of different places. Spouses have a conflict of interest and are too close to the situation to be able to objectively assess and diagnose. Comorbidity confuses people, so they make mistakes within their assessment due to their own lack of training. I actually used to get upset at the notion that significant others have no right to be assessing and diagnosing. I would say that I’m quite capable of identifying abuse and that I’m intelligent enough to be able to assess. However, after re...

Acceptance: It is what it is

  Acceptance: It is what it is Photo by  Daniel Uvegård  on  Unsplash Betrayal. Betrayal is hard to accept. It’s hard to get past when you know what you’ve been through and you can’t articulate it in a way that really provides the weight of the gravity and a sense of the urgency that the situation truly should call for. You find out that no one cares what happened to you. No one cares how wrong it was, or how illegal it was. They just want you to shut up so they don’t have to hear about it. So you found yourself discriminated against, you were shunned, you were isolated, and were systematically picked apart by the very people that you should have been able to trust. Then, after it all if you try to explain it to anyone you’re further isolated by their invalidation and inability to understand the true magnitude of what you’d been through. It amounts to a total betrayal by everyone you knew and the idea of having to let it go and let those people get away with it is a ...